The Myth

There's a well-worn saying often used to console someone after a stroke of bad luck: "Lightning never strikes the same place twice." The adage suggests that a rare, unfortunate event is unlikely to happen to the same person or in the same location again. It's a comforting thought, a verbal balm for misfortune. But is there any scientific truth to this popular proverb? This investigation will delve into the origins of this myth and uncover the electrifying reality of where and how often lightning truly strikes.

The Investigation: Where Did It Come From?

The saying "lightning never strikes the same place twice" is believed to have its roots in 19th-century literature, with one of the earliest known appearances in the 1860 book "Thrilling Adventures of the Prisoner of the Border" by P. Hamilton Myer. The phrase likely gained traction as a metaphor for the perceived rarity and randomness of lightning. In an era before advanced meteorological science, the chances of a single spot being hit by a seemingly random bolt from the blue seemed incredibly slim. This folk wisdom was passed down through generations, becoming a common way to express the unlikelihood of a rare event reoccurring. The idea behind the idiom is that a lightning strike is an unexpected and singular event. However, as our understanding of atmospheric electricity has grown, so has our realization that this proverb, while well-intentioned, is scientifically inaccurate.

The Evidence: What Does Science Say?

Modern science tells a very different story from the old adage. Far from avoiding a previous target, lightning can, and frequently does, strike the same place multiple times. The reason for this is rooted in the fundamental physics of a lightning discharge. Lightning is essentially a massive spark of electricity that is always seeking the path of least resistance between a charged cloud and the ground.

The Path of Least Resistance

During a thunderstorm, the air acts as an insulator between the positive and negative electrical charges that build up in the clouds and on the ground. When the charge difference becomes too great for the air to insulate, a discharge occurs, creating the flash of lightning we see. Certain features on the Earth's surface can provide a more conductive path for this electrical discharge. Tall, pointed, and isolated objects are particularly attractive to lightning because they shorten the distance the electrical charge has to travel through the air.

Skyscrapers: Nature's Lightning Rods

Some of the most compelling evidence against the myth comes from the world's tallest structures. These man-made giants act as giant lightning rods, drawing strikes away from their surroundings. The Empire State Building in New York City, for example, is struck by lightning an average of 23 to 25 times per year and has even been recorded being hit 8 times in 24 minutes. Similarly, Chicago's Willis Tower is a frequent target for lightning, having been struck 250 times between 2015 and 2020. The CN Tower in Toronto is another prime example, getting hit by lightning approximately 75 times annually. These repeated strikes are not a coincidence. The height and metallic composition of these buildings make them ideal conductors for the immense electrical energy of a lightning bolt. In fact, these skyscrapers are designed with sophisticated lightning protection systems to safely channel the electrical charge into the ground, preventing damage to the structure and protecting the people inside.

Natural Targets and Geographic Hotspots

It's not just skyscrapers that experience repeat lightning strikes. Natural features like mountains and tall trees are also frequently hit. Scientific studies have identified specific geographic locations around the globe that are lightning hotspots. Lake Maracaibo in Venezuela is considered the lightning capital of the world, with thunderstorms and lightning flashes occurring on up to 300 nights a year. Other lightning-prone areas include the Democratic Republic of the Congo and parts of Colombia and Pakistan. These regions have atmospheric conditions that are particularly conducive to the formation of thunderstorms, leading to a high frequency of lightning strikes in the same general areas. Even a single lightning flash can be composed of multiple strokes that follow the same path, which is why lightning sometimes appears to flicker. High-speed photography has revealed that what appears to be a single strike can actually be a series of discharges rapidly following the same ionized channel. Recent research using advanced radio telescopes has even identified structures within lightning called "needles" that can facilitate repeated discharges to the ground along the same channel.

The Verdict

The notion that lightning never strikes the same place twice is a pervasive and enduring myth. However, the scientific evidence is overwhelming and conclusive: lightning not only can but frequently does strike the same location multiple times. The behavior of lightning is governed by the laws of physics, not by folklore. It will always seek the most efficient path to the ground, and tall, conductive objects provide just that. From the world's tallest skyscrapers to mountain peaks, repeat lightning strikes are a well-documented and understood phenomenon. So, while the saying may offer a sense of comfort, it is a myth that has been thoroughly debunked by scientific investigation.

References

  • Britannica. (2025, September 5). Lightning.
  • Britannica Kids. (n.d.). lightning.
  • CTV News. (2023, April 6). This is the moment lightning struck the CN Tower during Ontario storm.
  • Element U.S. Space & Defense. (2019, March 29). Lightning Strikes Empire State Building.
  • Live Science. (2011, April 13). Video Captures Lightning Striking Empire State Building 3 Times.
  • NASA. (n.d.). Lightning Often Strikes Twice.
  • National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. (n.d.). Severe Weather 101: Lightning Basics.
  • NYC Microseasons. (2022, July 27). Summer Lightning Strikes the Empire State Building.
  • Science Alert. (2024, April 6). Lightning Really Does Strike Twice, And This Is Where It Happens Most.
  • STEAM Ahead. (2025, February 5). MythBuster: Lightning Never Strikes the Same Place Twice.
  • The Independent. (2024, May 30). Watch moment lightning strikes Empire State Building in New York.
  • Times of Malta. (2025, April 12). Myth debunked: Lightning never strikes the same place twice.
  • UCAR Center for Science Education. (n.d.). Lightning and Thunder.
  • Wikipedia. (n.d.). Distribution of lightning.
  • Writing Explained. (n.d.). What Does Lightning Never Strikes The Same Place Twice Mean?
  • Xweather. (2024, June 25). Myth, busted: Lightning can (and does!) strike the same place twice.
  • Yahoo News UK. (2019, April 17). Lightning 'strikes the same place twice quite often', say scientists.